Economic Perspectives in Colonial America
Procedures
About | Background | Objectives | Procedures | Assessment | Worksheet | Resources
This lesson combines the teaching of a useful technology skill, working with spreadsheets, with the comprehension of economic aspects of historical phenomena. This lesson is appropriate to teach during a unit on colonial North American History or on the economic advantages of early America. Some background information is useful.
The fundamental question of the lesson is how could the American economy thrive and enjoy high standards of living yet not change in the colonial period? Activate students' background knowledge by having them give evidence that America was thriving in the colonial period. Have students generate some reasons why America is currently such a strong economic power. If students are struggling, have them think about what sorts of conditions are necessary for economic growth. Some possible answers are: natural resources, skilled and energetic labor, capital, land, and infrastructure with abundance in any category as an advantage.
Students will examine a spreadsheet of population statistics to begin to look for keys to America's economic growth. While colonial North America enjoyed an extremely high rate of population growth which students will discover when they look at the data, it actually suffered from underpopulation and subsequent labor scarcity. How could a region thrive economically in such a region? Students will hypothesize about this dilemma as they move through the lesson. A student worksheet is available to print out which is helpful to have beside the computer while working in Excel.
Students should open the spreadsheet entitled Population in the North American Colonies - 1620-1780. This spreadsheet is very basic and some more sophisticated adaptations are included later for more advanced students. Students' first task is to put the data into a graphical format to look for trends. The CHART function in Excel creates a graphical representation of the data highlighted.
How to make a simple Excel chart:
Once students have all made a chart from the population data, have them discuss what they see. What is striking about the line? Without a standard of comparison, it is hard for this data to be particularly meaningful.
To help students gain some historical perspective, an additional spreadsheet with comparative data is included on sheet 3 (tab in lower left). They will compare the changes between 1700-1780 with growth from 1900-1980. Graphing the raw numbers on the same chart is not useful since only a tremendous scale would provide enough detail to make the two comparable. Instead, have students calculate the percent the population has changed in the two periods and then graph those two sets of numbers. This will also help them become more familiar with Excel.This calculation can be easily done with spreadsheet functions. Students should come up with a formula to calculate how much the population has changed over each ten year period. They will calculate these figures only for the data from 1700-1780 and from 1900-1980. Students should click on sheet 3 of the new spreadsheet to find the sheet on which they should work. There is a column for percent change where they will input their calculations and the additional data for the period 1900-1980. If students need help with the mechanics of this, they should read the section below.
How to calculate percentages in Excel:
Students are now ready to graph their percentage changes and compare the two centuries. As before, highlight the cells which will be graphed. Begin with A4:A11. Then, press the control key and move the mouse to highlight C4:11 and then again to highlight F4:11.Three columns should be highlighted. Follow the same procedure above (Insert...Chart...XY Scatter). In Step 2, select the Series Tab so you can label which series is 1710-1780 and which is 1910-1980. In Step 3, give the axes labels. It will be helpful to call the X axis Decades so it will be applicable for the 1700s and 1900s. Again, once the chart is graphed it can be re-sized. A sample graph is included for teachers under the Sheet 2 tab.
Students are finally ready to make some observations about population growth in the 18th century once they scrutinize their new chart.
Try to get students to realize that growth in population can come from both natural increase and migration. Today, most of America's growth comes from migration. Are there economic consequences of this?
Migration was the dominant source of population growth only in the first decades of settlement in each region. For example, immigration virtually halted in New England in the late 1640s. Population growth can be attributed to natural causes in most of the 18th century. It is worth noting that white birthrates in North America per 1000 women were between 45 and 55 per year compared with near 30 in Europe or 12 in the United States today. Additionally, the colonial population was quite young and in their prime childbearing years. Colonial women married earlier than in Europe. Furthermore, the death rate was about 20 to 25 per 1000 in North America versus 40 in Europe. Plentiful food supplies, fuel and housing helped counter the minimal medical care available.
LAND ABUNDANCE is a crucial and defining point in American economic history. It has been called the single most important element in the American economy from 1600-1900. The amount of land available for settlement was always higher than the growth in population during that period. The economic consequences were profound. It was much easier to become wealthy when land was so abundant, and colonial America enjoyed a very high standard of living. America became a predominantly agricultural country rooted in its rich land. Upward social mobility was possible for a large majority of the population, and a vast middle class developed.
Have students try to generate examples when it has and has not been in history and draw some conclusions. Population alone does not translate into economic growth. It must be combined with some of the other elements of a healthy economy mentioned earlier such as land, skill, capital, infrastructure. See if students can match a populous society with a lack of each of these terms and then discuss that society's economic health.
Emphasize land abundance. See if students can make this connection themselves. Underscore the idea of the favorable resource ratio in colonial America. Available land always exceded growth in population so America could continue to thrive economically without industrializing or changing production methods. With mostly rich soil, a favorable climate, and plenty of land, America was destined to thrive.